{ "meta": { "n": 75, "agree": 45, "partial": 26, "split": 4, "materialDisagreementPct": 40, "avgAgreement": 79 }, "results": [ { "cat": "health", "q": "Is it safe to take ibuprofen if I'm taking lisinopril for high blood pressure?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "ChatGPT says occasional use is 'typically fine' while Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity frame it as generally unsafe or not recommended, creating a materially different default stance on casual use.", "stance": { "Claude": "no - avoid, use acetaminophen", "ChatGPT": "depends - occasional use fine", "Gemini": "no - not recommended, ask doctor", "Mistral": "depends - short-term sometimes acceptable", "Perplexity": "no - generally not safe, use acetaminophen", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "I've had a sore throat for 4 days with a mild fever. Should I take antibiotics?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 95, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - get tested first", "ChatGPT": "no - see doctor first", "Gemini": "no response provided", "Mistral": "no - monitor then test", "Perplexity": "no - get tested first", "Grok": "no response provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Is intermittent fasting safe and effective for a 55-year-old with type 2 diabetes?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 92, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes, with medical supervision", "ChatGPT": "yes, with medical supervision", "Gemini": "yes, with medical supervision", "Mistral": "yes, with medical supervision", "Perplexity": "yes, with medical supervision", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Should a healthy 30-year-old get the annual flu vaccine?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 99, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes – safe widely recommended", "ChatGPT": "yes – protects self and community", "Gemini": "yes – reduces spread protects vulnerable", "Mistral": "yes – CDC recommends for all", "Perplexity": "yes – high efficacy low exceptions", "Grok": "N/A – not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "In France, can my landlord keep my security deposit for normal wear and tear after I move out?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 98, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no, cannot keep deposit", "ChatGPT": "no, cannot keep deposit", "Gemini": "no, cannot keep deposit", "Mistral": "not present", "Perplexity": "no, cannot keep deposit", "Grok": "not present" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "If a guest slips on the icy walkway outside my house, am I legally liable?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Perplexity leads with 'not automatically liable' and emphasizes natural accumulation protection, while Gemini and Mistral lean more affirmatively toward likely liability, creating materially different risk framing for the homeowner.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends + clear salt document insure", "ChatGPT": "depends + clear salt walkways", "Gemini": "yes + clear salt warn guests", "Mistral": "yes + clear salt warn document", "Perplexity": "not automatically + depends on cause/timing", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Can my employer in France legally require me to work on a public holiday?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes, except May 1st, check convention collective", "ChatGPT": "depends, check contract and collective agreement", "Gemini": "yes, check contract and collective agreement", "Mistral": "yes except May 1st, check contract or agreement", "Perplexity": "yes for non-May-1st holidays, check contract/agreement", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "I have a 4% mortgage and €30k savings. Should I pay down the mortgage early or invest in an index fund?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 82, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes - invest, split suggested", "ChatGPT": "depends - invest if risk-tolerant", "Gemini": "yes - invest in index fund", "Mistral": "depends - split or invest", "Perplexity": "yes - invest in index fund", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "I drive 15,000 km a year. Is it financially smarter to lease or buy a new car?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 85, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "buy – unambiguous recommendation", "ChatGPT": "buy – with mild hedging", "Gemini": "buy – clear recommendation", "Mistral": "buy – with lease caveat for lifestyle preference", "Perplexity": "buy – despite confused km/miles analysis", "Grok": "N/A – not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Should I withdraw from my retirement account to pay off €15k of credit-card debt at 20% APR?", "verdict": "SPLIT", "agreementScore": 35, "disagreement": "Gemini explicitly recommends withdrawing from retirement to pay off the debt immediately, while Claude, ChatGPT, and Perplexity all recommend against withdrawal and treating it as a last resort.", "stance": { "Claude": "no - exhaust alternatives first", "ChatGPT": "no - last resort only", "Gemini": "yes - pay off immediately", "Mistral": "n/a - not provided", "Perplexity": "no - alternatives strongly preferred", "Grok": "n/a - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should a solo freelance developer in France register as micro-entreprise or set up a SASU?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 92, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "micro-entreprise first, switch later", "ChatGPT": "micro-entreprise for simplicity, SASU for growth", "Gemini": "micro-entreprise first, switch later", "Mistral": "not present", "Perplexity": "micro-entreprise unless high revenue", "Grok": "not present" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Is it worth buying a 10-year-old used BMW with 150,000 km, or is the maintenance risk too high?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 62, "disagreement": "Claude and ChatGPT leave the door open conditionally (clean inspection, low price, repair buffer), while Gemini and Perplexity recommend against it more categorically regardless of condition.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - avoid unless very cheap and clean", "ChatGPT": "depends - possible if well-maintained", "Gemini": "no - high risk outweighs savings", "Mistral": "no stance - not present", "Perplexity": "no - generally not worth it", "Grok": "no stance - not present" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I accept a job offer with 20% higher pay but a 90-minute commute each way?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 68, "disagreement": "Mistral uniquely recommends trying the job for 1-2 months before deciding, while others lean toward declining outright or negotiating alternatives without a trial period.", "stance": { "Claude": "no – negotiate hybrid first", "ChatGPT": "depends – weigh costs and growth", "Gemini": "no – decline outright", "Mistral": "depends – trial it 1-2 months", "Perplexity": "no – decline firmly", "Grok": "N/A – not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Is nuclear power a safe and good choice for reducing carbon emissions?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes, important climate tool", "ChatGPT": "yes, part of balanced mix", "Gemini": "yes, safe and clean", "Mistral": "yes, combine with renewables", "Perplexity": "yes, necessary but not sole solution", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will the EUR/USD exchange rate likely be higher or lower in 12 months?", "verdict": "SPLIT", "agreementScore": 30, "disagreement": "Claude, ChatGPT, and Perplexity lean toward EUR/USD being lower (USD stronger), while Gemini and Mistral explicitly recommend expecting EUR/USD to be higher driven by narrowing rate differentials.", "stance": { "Claude": "no - USD stronger, lower EUR/USD", "ChatGPT": "no - lower if trends continue", "Gemini": "yes - marginally higher EUR/USD", "Mistral": "yes - slightly higher 1.10-1.15", "Perplexity": "no - lower ~1.00-1.09", "Grok": "n/a - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Should I take daily low-dose aspirin to prevent heart disease if I'm 50 with no heart problems?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 91, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no – consult doctor first", "ChatGPT": "no – consult doctor", "Gemini": "no – focus on lifestyle", "Mistral": "no – unless ≥10% CVD risk", "Perplexity": "no – don't start alone", "Grok": "n/a" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Is it safe to drink alcohol while taking metronidazole?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 78, "disagreement": "All agree alcohol must be avoided, but they differ on the post-treatment waiting period: Claude and ChatGPT and Mistral say 48 hours, Gemini says 72 hours, and Perplexity says 2-3 days, which is a materially different safety caveat a user would act on.", "stance": { "Claude": "no, avoid; wait 48hrs", "ChatGPT": "no, avoid; wait 48hrs", "Gemini": "no, avoid; wait 72hrs", "Mistral": "no, avoid; wait 48hrs", "Perplexity": "no, avoid; wait 2-3 days", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "My 2-year-old has a fever of 39°C. Should I go to the emergency room now?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 91, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends – call pediatrician first", "ChatGPT": "depends – monitor, call pediatrician", "Gemini": "depends – call pediatrician now", "Mistral": "depends – call pediatrician, ER if warning signs", "Perplexity": "depends – call pediatrician, not ER unless serious", "Grok": "N/A – not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Are creatine supplements safe for long-term daily use?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 96, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes, safe 3-5g/day", "ChatGPT": "yes, safe recommended doses", "Gemini": "yes, safe long-term", "Mistral": "yes, safe low-risk", "Perplexity": "yes, safe healthy adults", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Should a 45-year-old man get a PSA test for prostate cancer screening?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 68, "disagreement": "Perplexity uniquely endorses a baseline PSA at 45 for all men as potentially useful, while Gemini leans more firmly against routine screening, and others strictly condition testing on high-risk status only.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends – high-risk start now", "ChatGPT": "depends – consult doctor first", "Gemini": "no – unless high-risk", "Mistral": "depends – wait if average-risk", "Perplexity": "yes – baseline useful for all", "Grok": "N/A – not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Is a ketogenic diet safe for someone with high cholesterol?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 55, "disagreement": "Claude and ChatGPT say 'it depends, consult doctor and monitor,' while Gemini and Perplexity lean toward 'generally avoid/not recommended,' representing meaningfully different default stances on whether to proceed at all.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - consult doctor, monitor closely", "ChatGPT": "depends - consult doctor first", "Gemini": "no - generally not recommended", "Mistral": "N/A - not provided", "Perplexity": "no - generally not safe, avoid", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "In France, can I legally record a phone call without telling the other person?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 78, "disagreement": "Mistral introduces a notable caveat that recording for personal use may receive judicial leniency, and Perplexity highlights a court exception allowing unauthorized recordings as evidence in rare litigation cases, while Claude and Gemini give a cleaner 'always get consent' bottom line.", "stance": { "Claude": "no - always get consent", "ChatGPT": "not assessed", "Gemini": "no - always get consent", "Mistral": "no - but personal use may be lenient", "Perplexity": "no - but rare court exceptions exist", "Grok": "not assessed" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "If I find cash on the street, am I legally allowed to keep it?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Mistral uniquely suggests small amounts (e.g., $20 or less) are generally safe to keep without reporting, while all others recommend turning in cash regardless of amount.", "stance": { "Claude": "no - turn in first", "ChatGPT": "no - turn in first", "Gemini": "no - turn in immediately", "Mistral": "depends - small amounts keep, large amounts report", "Perplexity": "no - report to police", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Can my homeowners association legally fine me for parking in my own driveway?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 82, "disagreement": "Perplexity emphasizes HOAs generally cannot fine for private driveway parking unless CC&Rs explicitly allow it, while Gemini leans toward HOAs likely can, but all converge on the same action: check your CC&Rs.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends, review CC&Rs", "ChatGPT": "yes if CC&Rs allow, check them", "Gemini": "yes likely, review CC&Rs", "Mistral": "depends on CC&Rs, check them", "Perplexity": "generally no unless CC&Rs say so", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Is it legal to fly a drone over my neighbor's property in France?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 82, "disagreement": "Mistral uniquely suggests flying above 150m as 'typically safer', which contradicts standard DGAC rules and the other models' blanket advice to avoid flying over neighbor's property entirely.", "stance": { "Claude": "no - get explicit consent first", "ChatGPT": "no - avoid without explicit consent", "Gemini": "no - stay within own land boundaries", "Mistral": "no - but implies 150m altitude workaround", "Perplexity": "no - explicit permission required", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Can my employer in France legally read personal emails I sent from the work computer?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - label personal emails clearly", "ChatGPT": "no - mark emails personal", "Gemini": "no - but label clearly", "Mistral": "N/A - not provided", "Perplexity": "no - use personal account", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Should I buy or rent a home if I plan to stay only 4 years?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 95, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no — rent, 5-7yr rule", "ChatGPT": "no — rent, flexibility wins", "Gemini": "no — rent, costs too high", "Mistral": "no — not evaluated", "Perplexity": "no — rent, breakeven too long", "Grok": "no — not evaluated" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Is it smart to put 10% of my retirement portfolio into Bitcoin?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 62, "disagreement": "Claude conditionally endorses 5-10% for younger investors while others cap recommendations at 1-5% maximum, making Claude meaningfully more permissive than the consensus", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - 5-10% okay for young", "ChatGPT": "no - start with 1-5% max", "Gemini": "no - limit to 1-2% only", "Mistral": "no - limit to 1-5%", "Perplexity": "no - limit to 1-3%", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Should I take a loan from my 401k to fund a home down payment?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - explore alternatives first", "ChatGPT": "no - last resort only", "Gemini": "no - exhaust other options", "Mistral": "depends - job stability required", "Perplexity": "no - alternatives first", "Grok": "no data provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Is whole life insurance a good investment?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no – buy term instead", "ChatGPT": "depends – consider alternatives", "Gemini": "N/A – not provided", "Mistral": "no – buy term instead", "Perplexity": "no – term plus investing better" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Should I pay for my child's college, or have them take student loans?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 92, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - hybrid approach, retirement first", "ChatGPT": "depends - balanced contribution, retirement first", "Gemini": "depends - hybrid approach, retirement first", "Mistral": "depends - pay what you can, retirement first", "Perplexity": "depends - pay if possible, retirement first", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I quit my stable job to start my own business at 35 with two kids?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 92, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - build while employed", "ChatGPT": "conditional yes - needs plan/cushion", "Gemini": "no - validate on side first", "Mistral": "n/a - not provided", "Perplexity": "no - side project first", "Grok": "n/a - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Is an MBA worth the cost for a mid-career software engineer?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Gemini gives a hard 'do not pursue' while Claude, ChatGPT, and Perplexity leave meaningful room for career-transition scenarios where an MBA is justified.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends — only specific transitions", "ChatGPT": "depends — management/business goals", "Gemini": "no — rarely worth it", "Mistral": "n/a — not provided", "Perplexity": "no — only if 100% leaving engineering", "Grok": "n/a — not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I relocate my family to another country for a 30% salary increase?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 82, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - run real numbers first", "ChatGPT": "depends - analyze all factors thoroughly", "Gemini": "depends - no without deeper analysis", "Mistral": "depends - verify cost of living and fit", "Perplexity": "depends - calculate net disposable income first", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I tell my manager I'm interviewing elsewhere to try to get a counteroffer?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Perplexity leans hardest against counteroffers entirely and advises negotiating before job searching, while others conditionally allow disclosing if you have a real offer and are prepared to leave.", "stance": { "Claude": "no, wait for offer first", "ChatGPT": "depends, have offer first", "Gemini": "no, only with concrete offer", "Mistral": "depends, be ready to leave", "Perplexity": "no, avoid counteroffers entirely", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "In tech, is it better to specialize deeply or stay a generalist?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 62, "disagreement": "Gemini recommends specialization as the clear default, while Claude, Mistral, and Perplexity advocate for T-shaped skills as the ideal, and ChatGPT defers entirely to personal preference without a directional lean.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends + T-shaped is ideal", "ChatGPT": "depends + purely personal choice", "Gemini": "yes + specialize as default", "Mistral": "depends + T-shaped hybrid best", "Perplexity": "depends + T-shaped recommended", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should couples merge all their finances after marriage?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 91, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - hybrid system recommended", "ChatGPT": "depends - hybrid system recommended", "Gemini": "no - hybrid system recommended", "Mistral": "depends - hybrid system recommended", "Perplexity": "depends - hybrid system recommended", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Is it a red flag if my partner wants to check my phone?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 62, "disagreement": "Gemini gives a firm 'do not allow it' recommendation while Claude and ChatGPT emphasize context-dependence and mutual discussion as potentially legitimate exceptions.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends – context and mutuality matter", "ChatGPT": "yes – but context and open talk", "Gemini": "yes – do not allow it", "Mistral": "n/a", "Perplexity": "yes – red flag, discuss but enforce privacy", "Grok": "n/a" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will remote work still be common in 5 years, or will offices win out?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 94, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes, hybrid dominates", "ChatGPT": "yes, hybrid becomes norm", "Gemini": "yes, hybrid dominates", "Mistral": "N/A not provided", "Perplexity": "yes, hybrid dominates", "Grok": "N/A not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will electric cars fully replace gas cars by 2035?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "Minor variance on projected EV new-sales share by 2035 (Mistral says 60-80%, Claude says 30-50%), but all agree full replacement will not happen", "stance": { "Claude": "no, decades beyond 2035", "ChatGPT": "no, challenges remain", "Gemini": "no, gas still prevalent", "Mistral": "no, but EVs dominate new sales", "Perplexity": "no, only new sales targeted", "Grok": "no data provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will AI cause mass unemployment within the next decade?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 92, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - disruption not unemployment", "ChatGPT": "no - shifts not mass unemployment", "Gemini": "no - transformation not scarcity", "Mistral": "no - shifts not collapse", "Perplexity": "no - reshape not eliminate", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will housing prices in major cities keep rising over the next 5 years?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 52, "disagreement": "Gemini expects stagnation or minor declines as the base case, while Perplexity and ChatGPT lean toward continued appreciation (even if slower), creating a meaningful split on the directional outlook.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends – uneven, market-specific", "ChatGPT": "yes – likely rising but slower", "Gemini": "no – slowdown or modest declines", "Mistral": "depends – slower growth, city-specific", "Perplexity": "yes – continued appreciation, slower pace", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "consumer", "q": "Should I buy a used Tesla or a new Toyota if reliability matters most?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 95, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes - buy new Toyota", "ChatGPT": "yes - buy new Toyota", "Gemini": "yes - buy new Toyota", "Mistral": "yes - buy new Toyota, minor used-Tesla caveat", "Perplexity": "yes - buy new Toyota", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "consumer", "q": "Is it worth paying for a VPN for everyday personal privacy?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 62, "disagreement": "Perplexity leans toward a clear 'yes, worth it for most people' while Gemini and Claude lean toward 'probably not necessary unless specific use cases apply'", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - only for specific use cases", "ChatGPT": "depends - worth it if privacy is priority", "Gemini": "no - not essential for most users", "Mistral": "n/a - not provided", "Perplexity": "yes - worth it for most people", "Grok": "n/a - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "consumer", "q": "Should a small business build its app natively or with a cross-platform framework?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 95, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes - cross-platform default", "ChatGPT": "yes - cross-platform default", "Gemini": "yes - cross-platform default", "Mistral": "not provided", "Perplexity": "yes - cross-platform default", "Grok": "not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Should I take vitamin D supplements year-round?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 65, "disagreement": "Perplexity leans toward winter-only supplementation as the default for most healthy adults, while Claude and Mistral lean toward year-round supplementation for most people with indoor/northern lifestyles, creating a materially different default action.", "stance": { "Claude": "yes, year-round for most indoors/northern", "ChatGPT": "depends, test first consult doctor", "Gemini": "depends, winter priority test first", "Mistral": "depends, test-driven dose adjustment", "Perplexity": "no, winter-only unless risk factors", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Is it safe to exercise with a mild cold?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 96, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes - light exercise, above-neck rule", "ChatGPT": "yes - light exercise, above-neck rule", "Gemini": "yes - gentle exercise, above-neck rule", "Mistral": "yes - low-moderate intensity, above-neck rule", "Perplexity": "yes - light exercise, above-neck rule", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Should I get my wisdom teeth removed if they aren't causing pain?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Gemini leans toward 'no removal needed if asymptomatic' as a default, while Claude and Mistral lean toward proactive removal if any concern exists, especially in younger patients.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends — remove if any concern", "ChatGPT": "depends — monitor unless dentist advises otherwise", "Gemini": "no — monitor unless problems confirmed", "Mistral": "depends — remove if young or risks found", "Perplexity": "no — evaluate first, remove only if indicated", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Is melatonin safe to take every night for sleep?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Perplexity uniquely raises a 2025 cardiovascular risk study suggesting potential heart failure risk, while Gemini is notably more discouraging ('generally not recommended') versus others framing it as cautiously acceptable short-term.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends – short-term ok, long-term consult doctor", "ChatGPT": "depends – consult doctor for nightly extended use", "Gemini": "no – not recommended, consult doctor", "Mistral": "depends – short-term ok, address root causes", "Perplexity": "no – not proven safe, cardiac risk concern", "Grok": "N/A – not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Should I start statins if my cholesterol is only borderline high?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 92, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends – lifestyle first, risk-stratify", "ChatGPT": "depends – lifestyle first, consult doctor", "Gemini": "depends – lifestyle first, consult doctor", "Mistral": "depends – lifestyle first, risk-stratify", "Perplexity": "depends – lifestyle first, risk-stratify", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "health", "q": "Is it safe to take ibuprofen and acetaminophen at the same time?", "verdict": "SPLIT", "agreementScore": 35, "disagreement": "Gemini explicitly says it is NOT recommended to take them at the same time and advises spacing them out, while Claude, ChatGPT, Mistral, and Perplexity all say it IS generally safe to take them together simultaneously.", "stance": { "Claude": "yes, safe to combine", "ChatGPT": "yes, safe to combine", "Gemini": "no, not recommended simultaneously", "Mistral": "yes, safe to combine", "Perplexity": "yes, safe to combine", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Can I be fired in France for a social-media post made on my personal time?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - protected but exceptions apply", "ChatGPT": "yes - possible if harmful/misconduct", "Gemini": "yes - possible if serious misconduct", "Mistral": "not reviewed", "Perplexity": "yes - possible but privacy settings matter", "Grok": "not reviewed" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Is it legal to resell concert tickets above face value?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - check local laws", "ChatGPT": "depends - check local laws", "Gemini": "generally legal with exceptions", "Mistral": "not assessed", "Perplexity": "depends - jurisdiction specific", "Grok": "not assessed" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Can my landlord enter my apartment without notice in France?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "Minor differences in specified notice periods (24hrs vs 48hrs vs unspecified) but all agree landlord cannot enter without notice except emergencies", "stance": { "Claude": "no, except emergencies", "ChatGPT": "no, except emergencies", "Gemini": "no, consent required", "Mistral": "no, 24hr notice required", "Perplexity": "no, 48hr notice required", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Am I liable if my dog bites someone who entered my yard uninvited?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 62, "disagreement": "Mistral and Perplexity lean toward 'likely not liable' for trespassers, while Claude and ChatGPT emphasize you're 'not automatically off the hook' and may still face significant liability.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends, not off the hook", "ChatGPT": "depends, possible liability remains", "Gemini": "n/a", "Mistral": "likely not liable unless reckless", "Perplexity": "generally not liable unless negligent", "Grok": "n/a" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "legal", "q": "Can I legally refuse a breathalyzer test during a traffic stop in France?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 55, "disagreement": "Perplexity distinguishes between the initial screening test (éthylotest, refusable) and the verification test (éthylomètre, not refusable), while Claude, ChatGPT, and Mistral give a blanket 'you cannot refuse' answer with no such distinction.", "stance": { "Claude": "no - refusal illegal, criminal offense", "ChatGPT": "no - refusal illegal, comply", "Gemini": "no response provided", "Mistral": "no - refusal illegal, severe penalties", "Perplexity": "depends - initial test refusable, verification test not", "Grok": "no response provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Should I invest in individual stocks or only index funds?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 78, "disagreement": "Models agree on index funds as primary vehicle but meaningfully differ on how much to allocate to individual stocks: Claude suggests up to 20%, Mistral up to 10%, Perplexity caps at 5%, while Gemini recommends index funds exclusively.", "stance": { "Claude": "yes index funds, 10-20% stocks ok", "ChatGPT": "yes index funds, small portion stocks ok", "Gemini": "yes index funds exclusively", "Mistral": "yes index funds, under 10% stocks ok", "Perplexity": "yes index funds, max 5% stocks optional", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Is it worth paying points to lower my mortgage interest rate?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 97, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends on break-even timeline", "ChatGPT": "depends on break-even timeline", "Gemini": "depends on break-even timeline", "Mistral": "not included", "Perplexity": "depends on break-even timeline", "Grok": "not included" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Should I claim Social Security at 62 or wait until 67?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends – health/finances determine timing", "ChatGPT": "depends – wait if healthy/stable finances", "Gemini": "yes – wait until 67 if possible", "Mistral": "N/A – not provided", "Perplexity": "yes – wait until 67 or 70", "Grok": "N/A – not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "For a new business, is it better to lease equipment or buy it?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes - lease for new businesses", "ChatGPT": "yes - lease to preserve cash", "Gemini": "yes - lease is better", "Mistral": "yes - lease for most startups", "Perplexity": "depends - lease now buy long-term", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "finance", "q": "Should I keep 6 months of expenses in savings, or invest most of it?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - 3-6 months then invest", "ChatGPT": "depends - 3-6 months then invest", "Gemini": "yes - full 6 months then invest", "Mistral": "depends - 3-6 months then invest", "Perplexity": "depends - 3-6 months then invest", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I go back to school at 40 to change careers?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Perplexity leans affirmatively yes while others maintain a conditional depends framing, though all agree alternatives should be considered", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - research field requirements first", "ChatGPT": "depends - if benefits outweigh costs", "Gemini": "yes - if well-researched and purposeful", "Mistral": "depends - if goals and finances align", "Perplexity": "yes - often smart investment in growth fields", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Is it better to rent in the city or buy in the suburbs with a long commute?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 62, "disagreement": "Perplexity leans toward city renting as the default recommendation while others present it as a genuine depends-on-your-situation choice with no clear default winner.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - run the numbers", "ChatGPT": "depends - lifestyle vs investment", "Gemini": "depends - personal priorities", "Mistral": "depends - rent if commute over 45min", "Perplexity": "yes - rent city is default better", "Grok": "N/A" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I lend money to a family member who asks?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - only if affordable/gift-mindset", "ChatGPT": "depends - only if affordable/gift-mindset", "Gemini": "depends - only if affordable/gift-mindset", "Mistral": "not evaluated", "Perplexity": "depends - only if affordable/gift-mindset", "Grok": "not evaluated" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I have children before 30, or focus on my career first?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 82, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - readiness over timing", "ChatGPT": "depends - personal circumstances decide", "Gemini": "depends - values and stability matter", "Mistral": "depends - not applicable/not provided", "Perplexity": "depends - readiness over calendar", "Grok": "depends - not applicable/not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I confront a coworker who took credit for my work, or go straight to HR?", "verdict": "SPLIT", "agreementScore": 35, "disagreement": "Gemini recommends going straight to HR while all other models recommend direct confrontation with the coworker first", "stance": { "Claude": "yes - confront coworker first", "ChatGPT": "yes - confront coworker first", "Gemini": "no - go straight to HR", "Mistral": "yes - confront coworker first", "Perplexity": "yes - confront coworker first", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Should I sell my house now or wait, hoping prices rise?", "verdict": "PARTIAL", "agreementScore": 72, "disagreement": "Mistral and Perplexity lean more toward selling now citing near-peak prices and stalling appreciation, while Claude and ChatGPT explicitly avoid a directional recommendation and emphasize personal circumstances over market timing.", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - personal circumstances first", "ChatGPT": "depends - assess situation and trends", "Gemini": "N/A - not provided", "Mistral": "lean sell now - prices near peak", "Perplexity": "lean sell now - minimal upside waiting", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "decision", "q": "Is it worth hiring a personal trainer, or can I get results alone?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - situation-specific guidance", "ChatGPT": "depends - motivation and knowledge key", "Gemini": "yes - at least short-term", "Mistral": "depends - try a few sessions first", "Perplexity": "yes - especially for faster results", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will interest rates be higher or lower in 2 years?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 82, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "yes - moderately lower rates", "ChatGPT": "depends - stay informed, diversify", "Gemini": "yes - gradually lower rates", "Mistral": "yes - lower, stay flexible", "Perplexity": "yes - slightly lower rates", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will a college degree still be worth the cost in 10 years?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 88, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends on field/cost", "ChatGPT": "depends on field/goals", "Gemini": "yes with strategic choices", "Mistral": "not reviewed", "Perplexity": "yes with major/debt caveats", "Grok": "not reviewed" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will social-media use among teenagers decline in the next 5 years?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 92, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - shifts not declines", "ChatGPT": "no - platform shifts expected", "Gemini": "no - use stays high or increases", "Mistral": "n/a - not provided", "Perplexity": "no - heavy use continues", "Grok": "n/a - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "prediction", "q": "Will renewable energy be cheaper than fossil fuels everywhere by 2030?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 91, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - not universally, most places", "ChatGPT": "depends - many but not everywhere", "Gemini": "N/A - not provided", "Mistral": "depends - most regions not all", "Perplexity": "depends - dominant but not everywhere", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 4 }, { "cat": "consumer", "q": "Should I upgrade to the latest iPhone every year?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 95, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - upgrade every 2-3 years", "ChatGPT": "no - upgrade every 2-3 years", "Gemini": "no - upgrade every 2-3 years", "Mistral": "no - upgrade every 2-3 years", "Perplexity": "no - upgrade every 2-3 years", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "consumer", "q": "Is it worth buying an extended warranty on a new car?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 82, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "no - self-insure instead", "ChatGPT": "depends - keep car long-term", "Gemini": "no - save money separately", "Mistral": "no - with noted exceptions", "Perplexity": "no - unless 10+ year owner", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 }, { "cat": "consumer", "q": "Should I use a robo-advisor or a human financial advisor?", "verdict": "AGREE", "agreementScore": 95, "disagreement": "none", "stance": { "Claude": "depends - complexity/wealth threshold", "ChatGPT": "depends - complexity threshold", "Gemini": "depends - complexity threshold", "Mistral": "depends - complexity threshold", "Perplexity": "depends - complexity/hybrid approach", "Grok": "N/A - not provided" }, "answered": 5 } ] }